By the mere fact that this question is being raised, some Christians may feel uncomfortable or become enraged even. But this is a legitimate question when it comes to a person who is yet to accept Yeshua (Jesus’ true Hebrew name) as the Messiah. In my personal journey, I like many other Christians believed in the Old Testament because I believed in Jesus. But now I can confidently say that I believe in Yeshua because of the Tanakh (Old Testament).
The Scriptures were the basis for the New Testament writers to prove that Yeshua was truly the promised Messiah. Over and over, throughout the Gospels, we see the writers bring references from the Torah, Writings & Psalms to show how Yeshua fulfilled specific Prophecies, thereby proving to the reader that He is the promised One.
To the most part, Christians have grown up with the belief that Yeshua is this promised Messiah, and have had no need to question its authenticity.
Those who claimed to be or was pronounced to be Messiah
- Todah (Theudas) mentioned in Acts 5:36
- Judah HaG’lili (Judas of Galilee) mentioned in Acts 5:37
- Bar-Kosiba pronounced as Messiah by Rabbi Akiva in 132AD and given the name Bar-Kochva
- Sabbatai Zevi pronounced as Messiah in 1666
- Jacob Frank who proclaimed to be a Messiah in 1759
- Menachem Mendel Schneerson (1902-1994) who is believed to be the Messiah among the “Chabad” movement, and is said to be coming again.
- and many others…
Why believe Yeshua is the promised Messiah?
There are many prophecies about the Messiah in the Scripture, of which some prophecies are significant and clear while others are not. The clearest way to convincingly answer whether Jesus/Yeshua could be the promised Messiah would be to compare these Scriptures against His story. This story is laid out in detail throughout the 4 Gospels and some of the other Books and Letters of the New Testament. The main purpose of the Gospels were to prove to the reader that Yeshua is this promised Messiah. So let us compare the Prophecies and the fulfillments of the prophecies mentioned in the New Testament writings according to the witness of these writers who laid their lives for what they believed.
PROPHECY (Messiah must…) | Scripture Reference | Fulfillment |
Be the Seed made of a woman bruise the head of the serpent |
Gen 3:15 | Gal 4:4, 1Jn 3:8 |
Be the Seed of Abraham | Gen 12:3 | Mat 1:1, Gal 3:16 |
Be the Seed of Isaac | Gen 17:19, 21:12 | Mat 1:2, Luk 3:34, Heb 11:17-19 |
Be the Seed of Jacab Be the Star of Jacob |
Gen 28:14, Num 24:17-19 |
Mat 1:2, Luk 3:34, Rev 22:16 |
Descended from Judah | Gen 49:10 | Mat 1:2-3, Luk 3:33, Heb 7:14 |
Descended from David Heir to the Throne |
2Sam 7:12-13, Jer 23:5, Isa 9:6,7, 11:1-5 |
Mat 1:6, Rom 1:3, Luk 1:32 |
Exist Forever | Micah 5:2 | Joh 8:58, Col 1:15-19 |
Be the Son of God | Psalm 2:7, Pro 30:4 | Mat 3:17, Luk 1:32 |
Bear the Name of God (YHVH) | Jer 23:5,6 | Philip 2:9-11 |
To appear 69×7 Yrs after rebuilding the Wall of Jerusalem |
Dan 9:25,26 | Mat 2:1,16,19. Luk 3:1,23 |
Born in Bethlehem | Micah 5:2 | Mat 2:1, Luk 2:4-7 |
Be born of a Virgin | Isa 7:14 | Mat 1:18-25, Luk 1:26-35 |
Be Revered by Kings | Psa 72:10,11 | Mat 2:1-11 |
Follows a messenger who prepares the way |
Isa 40:3-5, Mal 3:1 | Mat 3:1-3, Luk 1:17, 3:2-6 |
Be anointed by the Spirit of God |
Isa 11:2, 61:1, Psa 45:7 | Mat 3:16, Joh 3:34 Act 10:38 |
Be a Prophet like Moses | Deut 18:15,18 | Act 3:20-22 |
Liberate the afflicted, proclaim freedom to the prisoners and proclaim the year of the Lord’s favor |
Isa 61:1,2 | Luk 4:18,19 |
Engage in a Healing Ministry | Isa 35:5,6, 42:18 | Mat 11:3-5 |
Lead a Ministry in Galilee | Isa 9:1-2 | Mat 4:12-16 |
Be Caring, Compassionate, Meek & Humble |
Isa 40:11, 42:1-3 | Mat 12:15-21, Heb 4:15 |
To be Sinless | Isa 53:9 | 1 Pet 2:22 |
Bear the Transgressions of others | Psa 69:9, Isa 53:12 | Rom 15:3 |
Be a High Priest after the order of Melchizedek |
Psa 110:4, | Heb 5:5,6, 6:20, 7:15-17 |
Enter Jerusalem riding on a Donkey | Zec 9:9 | Mat 21:1-11, Mar 11:1-11 |
Enter the Temple with authority | Mal 3:1 | Mat 21:12 – 24:1, Joh 2:13-22 |
Be hated without a cause | Psa 69:4, | Joh 15:24-15 |
Undesirable and rejected by His own people |
Isa 53:2, 63:3, Psa 69:8 | Mar 6:3, Joh 1:11, 7:3-5 |
Rejected by the rulers | Psa 118:22 | Mat 21:42, Joh 7:48 |
Rejected by Jews & Gentiles alike | Psa 2:1,2 | Act 4:25-27 |
Betrayed by a friend | Psa 55:12-14 | Act 1:16-18 Mat 26:21-25, 47-50; |
Be sold for 30 Pieces of Silver | Zec 11:12 | Mat 26:15 |
Pay the price for the Potter’s field | Zec 11:13 | Mat 27:3-10, Act 1:18,19 |
Must be abandoned by His disciples | Zec 13:7 | Mat 26:31,56 |
Be beaten with a Rod | Mic 5:1 | Mat 27:30 |
Be Beaten and Spat upon | Isa 50:6 | Mat 26:67, 27:30,31 |
Have His Feet and Hands Pierced | Zec 12:10, Psa 22:16,17 | Mat 27:35, Luk 24:39 Joh 20:25,27 |
Be craving of Thirst | Psa 22:15 | Joh 19:28 |
Be given Vinegar to Drink | Psa 69:21 | Mar 15:36, Joh 19:29 |
Have none of His bones broken | Psa 34:20, | Joh 19:33-36 |
Be Considered a Sinner | Isa 53:12 | Mar 15:28, Luk 22:37 |
Be put to death after 69×7 Yrs after rebuilding the Wall of Jerusalem |
Dan 9:24-26 | Mat 2:1, Luk 3:1,23 1Pet 3:18 |
Be a whose Death will be atonement to all mankind |
Isa 53:5-7,12 | Mar 10:45, Joh 1:29, 3:16, Acts 8:30-35 |
Be Buried among the Rich | Isa 53:9 | Mat 27:57-60 |
Rise again from the dead | Isa 53:9-10, Psa 16:10, Psa 2:7 |
Mat 28:1-20, Act 2:23-36, Act 13:33-37 |
Be lifted up to the right hand of God | Psa 16:11, 68:18, 110: 1 | Luk 24:51, Act 1:9-11, Act 7:55, Heb 1:3 |
Perform priestly duties in Heaven | Zec 6:13 | Rom 8:34, Heb 7:25, 8:2 |
Be the Cornerstone of God’s Congregation |
Isa 28:16, Psa 118:22,23 | Mat 21:42, Eph 2:20, 1Pet 2:5-7 |
Be the Person to whom even the Gentiles will turn to |
Isa 11:10, 42:1 | Mat 12:21, Rom 15:12, Act 10:45 |
Be accepted by the Gentile Nations as Ruler |
Isa 49:1-12, Psa 18:49, Deut 32:43, Psa 117:1 |
Rom 15:9-11 |
Fulfill God’s Appointed Days | Lev 23 | View the graph |
Conclusion
While there are many claimants to the Messiah-ship of God, there is only one person in history who fulfilled a large array of Scriptures to prove that He is indeed the Messiah. Any person who is unsure whether He truly matches this position must read and compare the Scriptures with the writings of the New Testament to see whether these match up. To those of us who firmly believe that Yeshua is indeed the promised Messiah, we should also know the reason for that belief is all of the evidence laid out in the New Testament pointing at the Scriptures. The Scriptures and the many pieces of evidence it puts forth is why we believe that Yeshua, unlike other claimants, is the real “Messiah Ben Joseph” who will return someday as “Messiah Ben David”.